# Fraud on the Rise: An Urgent Briefing on the State of Grant Payment Fraud for Nonprofits

> Chariot, Foundation Source, and Greater Houston Community Foundation came together for a candid conversation about a problem most organizations rarely talk about publicly: grant payment fraud. We looked at how check and ACH fraud actually happen, why it so often goes unreported, and the practical steps grantmakers and nonprofits can take to protect themselves.

- Canonical: https://givechariot.com/resources/webinars/fraud-on-the-rise-an-urgent-briefing-on-the-state-of-grant-payment-fraud-for-nonprofits
- Published: 2026-11-05

---

Chariot, Foundation Source, and Greater Houston Community Foundation came together for a candid conversation about a problem most organizations rarely talk about publicly: grant payment fraud. We looked at how check and ACH fraud actually happen, why it so often goes unreported, and the practical steps grantmakers and nonprofits can take to protect themselves.

Speakers:

- Stephen Kump, President, Foundation Source
- Mike Pawson, CFO & COO, Greater Houston Community Foundation
- Mitch Stein, Head of Strategy, Chariot

In this recap you'll learn:

- Why grant payments have become an easier target
- The tactics fraudsters use most often
- How verification works, and where fraud slips through at each step
- Best practices for grantmakers and for nonprofits

### 1. Why grant payments are an easy target

> “The world is just getting riskier each year... It’s getting smaller. So people from further away can do things to try to take your assets.” 

A few things make grant payments especially exposed:

- **Payments can go to organizations you’ve never spoken to:** Grants can go to any of roughly 1.5 million U.S. nonprofits, who often aren't expecting them \(DAFs, workplace giving, crowdfunding, etc.\).
- **Payment details arrive secondhand:** Updates to bank and address details can come from fundholders, not straight from the nonprofit itself.
- **Email can’t confirm who’s asking:** Hacked or lookalike email addresses make requests hard to trust.
- **Manual work is exposed to human error:** A high operational burden makes everyone more vulnerable, especially when compliance, payments, and grants teams work separately and fraudsters can slip through the gaps between them.
- **Fake donors:** Community foundations have seen people open donor accounts with ill intent, then impersonate a charity on the receiving end, in one case to claim a tax deduction on their own money.

### 2. The three places payment risk shows up

- **Compliance:** Can I pay this organization, and what if it isn’t listed with the IRS?
- **Mailed checks:** Where do I send a check in the mail, and how reliable is the mail?
- **ACH:** How do I confirm current bank details, and how do I handle them safely?

Mailed checks can feel like the safe default, but Mike shared a real world example he’s seen. A large grant check was stolen from the mail, and the fraudster opened a bank account in the grantee’s own name to deposit it. Because the check was never altered, Positive Pay had nothing to flag. It was only caught by good fortune.

> “I don’t know that I would want to mail a six-figure grant check and be bearing most of that risk myself if it goes missing, when I could do it electronically and have it be insured.”

Risk can start even earlier, with the donor. Stephen shared that he’s seeing people open donor accounts with bad intent, then pose as a charity to receive the grant. In one case he’d heard of, someone contributed their own money and impersonated the charity on the other end, likely to claim a tax deduction. Verifying donor identity at account setup, and giving grant approvers visibility into a donor’s history, can help flag a request that doesn’t look right.

### 3. The tactics fraudsters use most often

1. **Mail theft and fraud:** Grant checks are stolen from the mail, then washed, or deposited into accounts opened in the grantee’s name or a lookalike name.
2. **Phishing and compromised emails:** A hacked inbox, often a donor’s, board member’s, or partner’s, sends a convincing bank\-change request.
3. **Lookalike organization names and domains:** Fraudsters register names and email domains that are confusingly similar to a real nonprofit’s.
4. **“Bot” calls:** Automated or AI voices answer verification calls and pass as the real organization.
5. **AI\-generated documentation:** Forged bank letters, EIN letters and statements are now easy to produce and hard to spot.

Our panelists shared how these show up in practice:

- **A hijacked conversation:** This spring, a community foundation had their email compromised. The fraudster picked up an existing conversation and, after many back\-and\-forths, the situation escalated to attempted fraud.
- **A staged email thread:** At a recent conference, a community foundation shared how a lookalike donor email and a lookalike nonprofit email wrote back and forth, copying in a real program officer, to submit a grant request with new bank details. The long email history made the whole exchange look more legitimate.
- **Bot verification call:** One team spent 30 minutes on a verification call before realizing they were talking to a bot.

### 4. So, if this is so common, why isn’t anyone talking about it?

- **No one wants publicity for fraud:** The nonprofit sector has one of the lowest rates of reporting fraud, and of prosecuting it, because organizations worry about reputation and donor trust.
- **Losses can go unnoticed:** With DAF grants and other charitable payments, the nonprofit often doesn’t know a grant is coming. If it goes missing, neither the donor nor the charity may ever notice.
- **Reporting rarely leads anywhere:** Organizations that do report to the FBI’s IC3 or local police often hear nothing back, especially for smaller amounts or near misses.

But that silence has a cost as it lowers the chance that a fraudster is ever caught and it keeps organizations from warning the partners who could help.

> “If you’re not being semi-public about it, you can’t alert your partners who may also be able to help.”

### 5. A framework for auditing your own payment process

Every grant payment depends on three things: the right organization, the right person, and the right payment details.

You can use this framework to audit each step:

**Step 1:** Confirm the organization is eligible and in good standing by checking sources like OFAC and Secretary of State records. organization not on the IRS list, such as churches and some schools, need a manual 14\-point check.

- Fraud Openings: AI\-generated documentation is mostly likely to appear here, and database limitations on unlisted orgs create more vulnerability.

**Step 2:** Verify the individual. Confirm the person giving you details is who they say they are, and that they have the authority to act of the organization in question.

- Fraud Openings: Lookalike email domains and “bot” calls make this step harder than ever, so a familiar name or voice is no longer enough on its own.

**Step 3:** Verify the payment details. Confirm the bank account actually belongs to the organization in question and are still current. Payment details are the hardest to confirm, with bank account\-matching tools relying on "fuzzy" name matches and only covering participating banks, and many nonprofits using small community banks that aren’t included in that list.

> “The riskiest moment is at the point of change... a new payee or a changing account information. That is where the system is most vulnerable.”

Mike shared that his team at the GHCF uses a matching service through its bank that covers about two\-thirds of U.S. payments, yet they still get a definitive answer for less than 20% of its grantees. Even when a match comes back, it might be a “fuzzy match,” allowing for an account opened under a similar name to slip through.

### 6. Best practices for grantmakers

1. **Confirm the identity and authority of nonprofit leaders,** not just that a bank account matches the organization’s name.
2. 
  - Especially if you’re using a vendor to help with verification, especially generic bill payment, expense management, or accounts payable tools, confirm exactly how they validate that a nonprofit representative is who they say they are, and is a trusted leader to provide details.
3. **Require multi\-factor confirmation for bank details,** such as a call to a number you already have on file plus an email.
4. **Don’t rely solely on fundholders for payment changes.** Get a secondary confirmation from the nonprofit itself.
5. **Always issue checks with Positive Pay,** so your bank rejects any check you didn’t issue.
6. **Don’t allow fundholders to hand\-deliver checks.**
7. **Enforce a maximum grant size on mailed checks** and tell your bank what normal looks like, so unusual transfers get extra scrutiny.

### 7. Best practices for nonprofits

1. **Only allow your control person to provide payment details.**
2. **Track and manage every place you’ve given your bank details.**
3. **Educate staff on the heightened risks of phishing.**
4. **Enroll in electronic payments wherever possible,** and ask your bank about ACH Block, which stops unauthorized withdrawals from your account.
5. **Check your insurance policy,** including coverage for stolen funds and compromised email.
6. **Make yourself easy to verify:** list a phone number, address and key people on your website, and keep your IRS filings current.
7. **Vet grantmakers who reach out:** check the sender’s domain and look up the platform separately before sharing bank details.
8. **Flag risky processes to your grantmakers.**

### 8. What to do if something goes wrong

If a grant goes to the wrong account, move fast:

1. **Alert your bank immediately:** An ACH payment can usually only be reversed within about 24 hours.
2. **Inform the recipient or grantmaker, and the donor.**
3. **Report it to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center \(IC3\):** After your bank, it’s one of the fastest ways to flag large amount of stolen money that might still be recoverable.
4. **Check your insurance coverage:** For smaller losses, weigh whether a claim is worth it, since claims can affect future coverage.

### How Chariot applies this framework

At Chariot, we built Chariot Disbursements around the same three steps, with a focus on creating new deposit accounts where we own the first party diligence on individual identity and authority, vs. checking that an account number matches a organization name. Today, our network connects over 30 grantmakers and more than 21,000 nonprofits, covering about 56% of the sector’s donation volume.

1. Verifying the organization
2. 
  - We conduct a compliance review on an organization’s EIN to determine if they have an eligible “Nonprofit Code” and are in “Good Standing” with the IRS. This includes a review of 6 databases that are all refreshed in Chariot’s proprietary system on a daily or weekly basis.
  - If an organization is not listed with the IRS, we conduct our own verification process and gather additional documentation from them. Every grantmaker using Chariot disbursements benefits from this shared enriched database.
3. Verifying the individual
4. 
  - We confirm that the person claiming the account is both who they say they are \(via top\-tier personal identity verification providers\), is connected to the organization and has the authority to set up a financial account. We systematically check things like email domain match and listed officers on 990s, in addition to a live selfie with ID and other documentation requests.
5. Verifying the payment details
6. 
  - Once an organization and its owner is verified, it receives payments in one secure place: its Chariot Deposit Account\*. Only the verified owner can update their connected external financial account, which also triggers a series of additional checks and guardrails. This way bank details aren't shared or stored with any grantmakers.

If a nonprofit wants to receive a mailed check instead, we verify mailing address, and apply Positive Pay protections as standard, with real\-time tracking en route.

> “I’m very bullish on these payment networks, these disbursement networks that are emerging, Chariot being one... The more that you can collectively pool that risk, the lower likelihood that your organization would be on the receiving end of a tough situation with payments fraud.”

#### Keep the conversation going

This is a problem that gets worse in silence. If your organization has seen an fraud attempt, talking about it, even anonymously, helps the next team catch it sooner.

Want to talk through your own process, or see how Chariot Disbursements handles each step? Our team would love to chat.